Welcome to Fiesty Potatoes 🥔
Your guide to the best food experiences in NYC and beyond. From bakeries to fine dining, we explore the flavors that make this city amazing.
My All Time, Top 5 Bakeries in NYC
The Bakery Basket Series My All Time, Top 5 Bakeries in NYC (that focus on Western-European-American style breads) (aka we aren’t talking about a good old fashioned Canto coffee shop and bakery) (updated as of mid-2025) Only number 1 is ranked. The rest are in a random order. #1: Supermoon Bakehouse This page could have just been my love letter to Supermoon. I’ve been coming here since I moved to the city in 2017; It’s my most frequented bakery and I’ve seen it go through all its different skins through the years. Every baked good I’ve had is amazing, and I’ve had a lot. There was one time I got basically one of everything they had and brought a box to a bachelorette party. ...